Skip to main content

Accidents

Arco Avon (2015)

The report records one fatality but does not provide separate counts for non-fatal injuries or missing persons. No economic damage estimate is given.

Classification

  • Incident Type: Fire
  • Severity: High
  • Casualty classification: Very Serious Marine Casualty

Vessel Details

FieldValue
Vessel NameArco Avon
Vessel TypeOther
Flag StateUnited Kingdom [GB]
IMO Number8508383
Gross Tonnage3474
LOA (m)98.6
Year Built1986
Crew Size10

Incident Details

FieldValue
Date2015-08-18
LocationApproximately 12 nautical miles off Great Yarmouth, United Kingdom
RegionNorth Sea
Coordinates52.6000, 2.0000
Fatalities1
Injuries
Missing
Direct DamageFire damage to engine-room power cabling and control systems; smoke damage throughout the engine room.
Economic Damage

The report records one fatality but does not provide separate counts for non-fatal injuries or missing persons. No economic damage estimate is given.

Key facts

  • The fire began at 23:12 BST on 18 August 2015 while Arco Avon was loading sand off Great Yarmouth.
  • The third engineer was attempting to repair a leaking low-pressure fuel return pipe and was fatally burned.
  • MAIB investigators concluded that sparks from a portable angle grinder ignited atomised fuel and fuel-soaked clothing.
  • The crew activated the engine-room carbon-dioxide system, but the vessel lost main power and remained at anchor for nine days.

Narrative

Arco Avon was a UK-flagged suction dredger operated by Hanson Aggregates Marine Limited. The vessel left Dagenham at about 12:00 BST on 18 August 2015 and proceeded to a sand-loading area approximately 12 nautical miles off Great Yarmouth. Loading began at about 21:24. During dredging, the engine room was manned by a single engineer officer, and there had been no further communication between the bridge team and the third engineer before the fire.

At 23:12, a fire detector indicated a fire in the engine room. The third engineer called the bridge from the machinery control room and reported that he had been injured. He had to pass through the fire to reach the main deck, where the crew found him badly burned. Examination of the scene found a defective low-pressure fuel return pipe beneath the floor plates near No. 2 generator, together with an angle grinder and other repair tools. The MAIB concluded that the third engineer had attempted to remove a support and make a temporary repair while the main engine was running. Fuel under pressure atomised from the damaged pipe, soaked his overalls, and was ignited by high-energy sparks from the angle grinder.

The crew prepared a fire team, issued a Mayday, and requested evacuation of the injured engineer. Dense smoke and heat prevented entry into the engine room, so the fixed carbon-dioxide system was activated. About half of the cylinders initially failed to operate and were activated manually. The fire was brought under control, but the vessel lost main power. An RNLI lifeboat reached Arco Avon at 00:13 on 19 August, and a rescue helicopter took the third engineer to hospital at 01:37. He died from his injuries later that day. Arco Avon remained at anchor with dredging equipment partially deployed for nine days before being taken under tow and delivered to a repair facility.

Sequence of events

Date/timeEvent
2015-08-18 12:00 BSTArco Avon departed Dagenham for the loading area off Great Yarmouth.
2015-08-18 21:24 BSTSand loading began, with the engine room in a manned condition.
2015-08-18 23:12 BSTThe engine-room fire detector activated.
2015-08-18 23:25 BSTThe master broadcast a Mayday.
2015-08-18 23:38 BSTThe master reported that the engine room had been flooded with carbon dioxide.
2015-08-19 00:13 BSTAn RNLI lifeboat boarded Arco Avon and began treating the injured engineer.
2015-08-19 01:37 BSTA rescue helicopter departed with the third engineer for hospital.
2015-08-19The third engineer died from his injuries.
2015-08-27The vessel reached a repair and lay-by berth in Hull after salvage operations.

Contributing factors

FactorEvidence statusDescription
Fuel leak and ignition sourceConfirmed findingA defective low-pressure fuel return pipe released atomised fuel, and MAIB identified the angle grinder's high-energy sparks as the probable ignition source.
Unauthorised repair activitySuspectedThe third engineer attempted the repair without informing the bridge watchkeeper or chief engineer and without completing a formal risk assessment or permit to work.
Lone working and communicationSuspectedThe report identified routine lone working and the lapse in the required regular communication with the bridge as conditions that increased the risk of autonomous hazardous work.

Investigation

The Marine Accident Investigation Branch investigated the fire and published its report, Report on the investigation of a fire in the engine room on the suction dredger Arco Avon. The report concluded that the third engineer was attempting to repair a failed fuel pipe when pressurised fuel ignited, and that sparks from a portable angle grinder were the probable ignition source. It also identified the absence of a formal risk assessment or permit to work, together with lone-working and communication practices, as contributing circumstances.

References

Similar incidents