Definition
A tug capsize caused by the towline pulling the tug broadside or stern-to the direction of load, overwhelming its righting moment. The tug is "girded" — caught by its own towline and unable to recover.
Mechanism
- Tug is towing or assisting a large vessel
- The lead of the towline shifts to a beam or stern angle (perpendicular or near-perpendicular to the tug's heading)
- The lateral force from the towline exceeds the tug's transverse stability
- The tug heels rapidly and capsizes — often within seconds
- Crew have little or no time to respond or release the hook
Why it happens
- Tug gets out of position relative to the towed vessel
- Large vessel changes course or speed unexpectedly
- Tug operator cannot release the towhook in time
- Towhook release fails (see Towhook Failure)
- Poor communication between tug and pilot
Key risk factors
- Conventional towing hooks without automatic or quick-release mechanisms
- High bollard pull relative to tug's beam (more power than stability)
- Confined waters limiting the tug's maneuvering room
- Operating in a position where the towline can sweep aft
Related incidents
Accidents linked to this concept are grouped by vessel type.
Tug (55)
- 2023-02-24: Biter (2023)
- 2018-08-13: George H. Ledcor (2018)
- 2016-09-20: Domingue (2016)
- 2015-09-11: Ocean Gordon (2015)
- 2015-06-22: LCM131 (2015)
- 2015-06-19: Hodder Ranger (2015)
- 2015-03-30: Asterix (2015)
- 2014-10-06: Samantha J (2014)
- 2014-08-04: Diver Master (2014)
- 2014-07-07: Breezand, Y8018 (2014)
- 2014-02-22: Starkad (2014)
- 2013-11-05: Gudri (2013)
- 2013-06-10: North Tug (2013)
- 2013-05-26: Jascon 4 (2013)
- 2012-06-28: Sea Cap VII (2012)
- 2011-10-05: Warnoc (2011)
- 2011-06-11: Adonis (2011)
- 2011-06-03: En Avant 5 (2011)
- 2010-06-02: River Queen (2010)
- 2010-02-14: Sea Imp XV (2010)
- 2010-01-28: Iris G (2010)
- 2009-11-19: Connie E (2009)
- 2009-07-19: North Arm Venture (2009)
- 2009-06-14: Ijsselstroom (2009)
- 2009-03-07: Island Provider 1 (2009)
- 2008-07-11: TYR (2008)
- 2008-06-09: Sea Cap III (2008)
- 2007-12-19: Flying Phantom (2007)
- 2007-09-19: D & E No. 1 (2007)
- 2007-09-07: Boatman No. 5 (2007)
- 2007-07-27: Butler (2007)
- 2007-06-06: Glenshiel (2007)
- 2007-04-12: Bourbon Dolphin (2007)
- 2005-12-20: Manta (2005)
- 2005-10-15: Samantha J (2005)
- 2005-06-05: Multi Mammut (2005)
- 2005-03-20: Aqua Queen (2005)
- 2004-11-06: Manson (2004)
- 2004-03-14: Samantha J (2004)
- 2003-10-19: Stevns Power (2003)
- 2001-03-09: Nautilus III (2001)
- 2000-10-27: Stockton II (2000)
- 2000-07-05: Mahia (2000)
- 2000-06-23: 10D34138 (2000)
- 1999-07-19: Compass Rebel (1999)
- 1998-09-08: Trijnie (1998)
- 1996-11-11: Bever (1996)
- 1996-01-01: Smit Japan (1996)
- 1995-11-16: Duke Point (1995)
- 1995-02-12: Kaien Pride (1995)
- 1994-06-18: Savage Warrior (1994)
- 1993-11-13: Ida 1 (1993)
- 1992-06-06: Lady Moira (1992)
- 1991-06-20: Seaspan Rustler (1991)
- 1982-03-28: Temi IV (1982)
Other (2)
Related
- Tug Incident Classification
- Towhook Failure — often a contributing factor
- Capsize Not Girding